Emmie Caldwell (Mary Ellen Hughes): Craft Fair Knitters Mystery Series

Yikes, I’ve really gotten behind! I believe I mentioned a few posts ago that my daughter and her family have visited recently… well, recovering from that sort of excitement is starting to get harder and harder, so the last few weeks have left both myself and my husband a little behind. I’ll try to get back ‘on track’ as quickly as possible!

Anyway… for ‘this month’ (ie last month, June), I’ll be discussing the first entry in Emmie Caldwell‘s Craft Fair Knitters Mystery Series, A Wicked Yarn. it’s worth mentioning that I don’t usually highlight an author’s other pseudonyms in the name of this sort of book highlight post, but in this case, Mary Ellen Hughes is simply significantly more recognizable than Emmie Caldwell. It’s really unfortunate when authors do this, since I think it really hurts their new series – not to mention makes it harder for readers to find new works by authors they like. This is a relatively new series by Caldwell/Hughes, starting in 2020, so it’s safe to say it’s a very modern Cozy by this site’s standards.

It’s Mother’s Day weekend, and relatively recently widowed Lia Geiger is enjoying herself at the Crandalsburg Craft Fair, including managing the stall where she sells both her own and friends’ knitting products, and checking up with her old friend, Belinda, the fair’s manager. Lia has relatively recently moved to Crandalsburg as part of moving on from memories of her deceased husband, though not particularly far- just from another nearby small town, York. Belinda seems a bit on edge, even more so than normal for a holiday fair opening.

It doesn’t take long for Belinda to explain the problem. The owner of the barn where the craft fair is run is being sold – and worse, to Belinda’s ex-husband Darren, who will certainly shut it down. Well… he would shut it down, but unsurprisingly, he turns up dead before he can do so… right after Belinda and her ex exchange ambiguous, vaguely threatening phrases in front of the entire craft fair.

Well, fortunately, Lia isn’t about to let little things like an obvious motive and menacing phrasing keep her from believing in her friend’s innocence. Even more fortunately, there seems to be no shortage of suspects for Darren’s death, as is so often the case.

As with so many modern Cozies, this is definitely the sort of series where you’re really going to enjoy the series more if you’re interested in the hobby that is integrated into it. There are significant portions of the book where the goes into specifics regarding knitting projects, her time with her knitting circle, the stock and management aspects of Lia’s booth, and other crafting elements. That said, it also does one thing that I know many site readers will know, and that’s get right to the murder. The amount of pre-crime content is exactly what I like to see in a Cozy – a few pre-murder scenes to set the tone and establish the setting, then the sleuth stumbling across the crime scene.

All in all, I would call A Wicked Yarn a very solid modern Cozy with a good mix of mystery and theme-specific elements. If you’re looking for a mystery involving knitters, this is definitely a great pickup for any modern Cozy fan.

As always, if you want to read more of these brief discussions of some of the more popular Cozy Mystery Series that I’ve written in the past, you can find them at the Most Recommended Cozy Mystery Series page.