A Cozy Mystery reader recently wrote in a request to make a new sub-category for Amish themed Cozy Mysteries. I also decided to add Quaker, Shaker, and Mennonite themed mysteries to the list as well. Most of these are Amish themed – if I don’t say that it is Quaker, Shaker, or Mennonite >>> then it’s Amish. Here’s what we have so far, mostly provided by the requester. (Thank you, Ty, for this great Cozy Mystery theme idea!)

Amish, Quaker, Shaker, & Mennonite Cozy Mysteries:

Isabella Alan (aka Amanda Flower): Amish Quilt Shop Mystery Series

Susan Wittig Albert (aka 1/2 Robin Paige): Wormwood (book #17 of China Bayles Mystery Series) (Shaker)

Irene Allen: Elizabeth Elliot Mystery Series (book #1 Quaker Silence)

Madelyn Alt: Hex Marks the Spot (book #3 Bewitching Mystery Series

Annie’s Amish Inn Mystery Series

Tace Baker (aka Edith Maxwell & Maddie Day): Speaking of Mystery Mystery Series (Quaker Linguistics professor)

Laura Bradford (aka Elizabeth Lynn Casey): Amish Mystery Series

Linda Castillo: Kate Burkholder Series (book #1 Sworn to Silence) (thriller, not Cozy)

Vannetta Chapman: Amish Village Mystery Series AND Shipshewana Amish Quilt Shop Mystery Series

Mindy Starns Clark writes Amish non-mystery books and has written at least one Lancaster County mystery.

Jacqueline Fiedler: Amish Butter (story found in Unholy Orders: Mystery Stories with a Religious Twist anthology)

Amanda Flower (aka Isabella Alan): Appleseed Creek Mystery Series

Amanda Flower (aka Isabella Alan): Amish Matchmaker Mystery Series

P.L. Gaus: Ohio Amish Mystery Series

Shelley Shepard Gray: Secrets of Crittenden County Series (book #1 Missing)

Karen Ann Harper: Maplecreek Amish Trilogy & Home Valley Amish Mystery Series

Eleanor Kuhns: Will Rees Mystery Series (book #1 A Simple Murder & book #3 Cradle to Grave) (Shaker)

Edith Maxwell (aka Maddie Day & Tace Baker): Carriagetown Mystery Series  (Quaker)

Edith Maxwell (aka Maddie Day & Tace Baker): Quaker Midwife Mystery Series

Nancy Mehl: Harmony Mystery Series Trilogy & Road to Kingdom Mystery Series (Mennonite)

Emma Miller: Amish Mystery Series

Tamar Myers: Pennsylvania Dutch Inn Mystery Series (Mennonite)

Marta Perry: Three Sisters Inn Series (Amish)

Sugar Creek Amish Mysteries (Amish)

Deborah Woodworth: Shaker Mystery Series (Shaker)

Barbara Workinger: Amish Country Mystery Series (book #1 In Dutch Again)

Ron Yeakley: Death Takes a Buggy Ride

Can you think of any Amish, Quaker, or Shaker themed Cozies to add to the list? Let me know in the comments below!

♦To access more Cozy Mysteries by Theme click on this link.♦

Recently I was updating one of my favorite theme pages, the cat themed Cozy Mysteries (here is the link to that theme: Cat Theme Mysteries: Kittens, Cats, and Cozies), and it got me thinking about some of my favorite feline characters in Cozy Mysteries. (Thank you, Susan*, for recently bringing a few of the important Cozy Mystery cat characters I had missed to my attention!)

I’m particularly fond of Sophie, Betsy Devonshire’s cat from the Needlecraft Mystery Series, written by Monica Ferris. Sophie’s a fat, loveable, lazy cat, living with her owner above their yarn store. When Betsy’s needlework group comes over for their scheduled lunches, Sophie is continuously finding little tidbits to gobble down that one (or more!) of the needlecrafters dropped (possibly on purpose!) >>> even though Betsy seems to almost always have Sophie on a diet.

Do you have a favorite cat character from a Cozy Mystery series?  Please be sure to tell us about him/her AND a brief description of what makes him/her so lovable in the comments below.

P.S. I had not planned on making a list, but since your comments have reminded me of some terrific Cat Characters in Cozies, here’s a list of your favorite Cats in Cozy Mystery Series:

Susan Wittig Albert: China Bayles mysteries: Khat (previously known as ‘Pudding’)

Susan Whiting Albert: Cottage Tales of Beatrix Potter Mystery Series

Marian Babson: cat mysteries

Lorna Barrett: Booktown mysteries: Miss Marple

Ali Brandon: Black Cat Bookshop mysteries: Hamlet

Lilian Jackson Braun: The Cat Who ***** mysteries: Yum Yum & Koko

Rita Mae Brown: Mrs. Murphy mysteries: Mrs. Murphy & Pewter

Janet Cantrell (aka Kaye George): Fat Cat Mystery Series: Chase

Laurie Cass: Bookmobile Cat Mystery Series: Eddie

Cleo Coyle: Coffeehouse mysteries: Java

Claire Donally: Sunny and Shadow Mystery Series: Maine

Carole Nelson Douglas: Minight Louie mysteries: Midnight Louie

Monica Ferris: Needlecraft mysteries: Sophie

Joanne Fluke: Hannah Swensen mysteries: Moishe

Karen Anne Golden: The Cats That … Mystery Series: Scout, Iris, Lilac, Abbey, and Abra

Sally Goldenbaum: Seaside Knitters mysteries: Purl

Kerry Greenwood: Corinna Chapman mysteries: Lucifer, Horatio, & the Mouse Police

Kerry Greenwood: Phryne Fisher: Ember

Rebecca M. Hale: Cats and Curios mysteries: Rupert & Isabella

Carolyn (G.) Hart: Death on Demand: Agatha & Dorothy L

Simon Hawke: fantasy mysteries: Catseye Gomez

Miranda James: Cat in the Stack mysteries: Diesel

Sofie Kelly: Magical Cats mysteries: Owen & Hercules

Laura Levine: Jaine Austen mysteries: Prozac

Richard & Frances Lockridge: Mr. & Mrs. North Mystery Series (Pete is their cat.)

T.C. LoTempio: Nick and Nora Mystery Series: Nick

Blanche Day Manos: Darcy & Flora mysteries: Jethro

Shirley Rousseau Murphy: Joe Grey mysteries: Joe Grey, Dulcie, & Kit

Linda Palmer: Daytime mysteries: Magic

Sofie Ryan: Second Chance Cat mysteries: Elvis

Dell Shannon: Luis Mendoza mysteries: his cats, especially El Señor

Clea Simon: Pru Marlowe Pet Noir mysteries: Wallis

Karen Rose Smith: Caprice DeLuca mysteries: Sophia

Fran Stewart: Biscuit McKee & Marmalade Mystery Series: Marmalade

Leann Sweeney: Cats in Trouble mysteries: Syrah, Merlot, & Chablis

(I have also included the cats that were recommended on my Facebook page.)

♦To access more Cozy Mysteries by Theme click on this link.♦

In my last post, I discussed Knox’s Commandments, a set of “fair play” rules that were written in the late 1920s and helped form much of the “golden era” of Cozy Mystery writing (then considered detective fiction). This time I’m going to go through some of the rules I think still retain relevance today and are worth discussing. Obviously, some of them have basically been discarded by the sands of time. (Again, I’m sorry that the rules are dated, and that some of them are phrased in a way that makes them uncomfortable to modern sensibilities.)

Rule 1 – “The criminal must be someone mentioned in the early part of the story, but must not be anyone whose thoughts the reader has been allowed to follow.”

As with most of the “rules”, this is one that’s been broken before, occasionally to good effect. It’s still not generally recommended for less experienced authors since pulling it off without feeling unfair is quite difficult, but I wrote an earlier blog about authors such as Agatha Christie who were able to make it work.

Rule 2 – “All supernatural or preternatural agencies are ruled out as a matter of course.”

Of Knox’s Commandments, this is perhaps the rule most thoroughly discarded in modern Cozy Mysteries. Especially in recent years, there has been an increase in paranormal or supernaturally themed Cozies where criminal and detective alike have some sort of supernatural hook such as witchcraft or mild psychic powers. Simply summarily solving the crime through magic should probably still be avoided – just saying “the detective casts a spell and now knows who committed the crime” still shouldn’t happen.

Rule 4 – “No hitherto undiscovered poisons may be used, nor any appliance which will need a long scientific explanation at the end.”

By “undiscovered”, Knox means that the poison should be known to medical science, and if at all possible detectable by autopsy. I think this rule should be considered a good one – if the authorities bother to look carefully for a cause of death, an autopsy or similar test shouldn’t come back inconclusive. That said, poisons that make a murder look like something else to casual observation are still fair play, so long as the eventual cause of death can be determined to be murder in the end.

Rule 6 – “No accident must ever help the detective, nor must he ever have an unaccountable intuition which proves to be right.”

Knox clarifies that this isn’t intended to mean that the detective can’t have a flash of intuition where previously observed evidence suddenly makes the solution clear to him, but rather that he shouldn’t be able to, in Knox’s words, “to look for the lost will in the works of the grandfather clock because an unaccountable instinct tells him that that is the right place to search.” If the detective comes across the hidden will through hard work and dedication, such as by searching the entire house from top to bottom, that’s fine. This rule can sometimes be broken, especially if the detective is associated with the paranormal. For more mundane detectives, it should generally remain intact.

Rule 7 – “The detective must not himself commit the crime.”

I’d say this is an important rule, both today and when it was first written. It hardly seems fair for the detective to gather together all the suspects and then declare that it was in fact… himself! Knox also points out that this is only a solid rule when the author vouches for the character as a detective – a criminal posing as a police officer is still fair, especially if some reason to doubt their identity is introduced.

Rule 8 – “The detective must not light on any clues which are not instantly produced for the inspection of the reader.”

This rule has been broken before and will be broken again, but I personally think it’s unfair. If the crucial piece of evidence isn’t visible to the audience, it feels like the author is cheating and that the mystery simply isn’t solvable for the audience.

Rule 9 – “The stupid friend of the detective, the Watson, must not conceal any thoughts which pass through his mind; his intelligence must be slightly, but very slightly, below that of the average reader.”

Knox also points out that this rule only applies if there is a “Watson”. I think this is a good rule to aim for, but harder to hit – writing an assistant as slightly below average intelligence is a tough goal for many authors.

Yikes! That sure was a lot of rules! It is a bit surprising how well many of the rules hold up – I guess what was fair to the reader when they were first written in the 1920s can still be generally considered fair today!

Which of the rules do you think are the most abused today? Do you think some of the rules I see as discarded haven’t been? What is your opinion about Knox’s (10) Commandments in today’s Cozy Mysteries? Are there other rules you think should be substituted for these? (For instance, I would suggest a rule where the sleuth doesn’t always fall into peril as part of the plot of every book in the series.)

The Detection Club

Knox’s Commandments – The 10 Rules of Golden Age Detective Fiction, Part 1

In 1929, Golden Age mystery writer and monsignor of the Catholic Church Ronald Knox formulated 10 rules that he believed should set apart proper detective fiction from what he considered “shockers”,  works that primarily dealt with heroes fighting criminal enterprises rather than detectives attempting to solve a mystery. Called Knox’s Commandments, these rules would quickly become the standing guidelines for the Detection Club, which I discussed in my previous post. Other sets of similar guidelines would emerge in the era – such as S.S. Van Dines’s “Twenty Rules for Writing Detective Stories”, actually published before Knox’s own Commandments – but it would be Knox’s rules that would by and large dominate the Golden Age of Crime, supported as it was by the Detection Club (which included Agatha Christie) and its roster of talented mystery writers.

Even Knox never expected full compliance with the rules he set out – he freely admitted that some truly worthy mystery works would occasionally break the rules and end up the better for it – but by and large these were considered a good set of guidelines, and authors would stray from them at their own peril. In my next post in this series, I intend to go through Knox’s Commandments one by one and discuss how they either apply or no longer apply in mystery fiction. For now, I’ll just post the Commandments themselves for your consideration.

Keep in mind that these rules were written in a very different time – since the rules are dated, some of the rules are phrased in a way that makes them very uncomfortable to modern sensibilities, though they wouldn’t have been considered out of place in the era they were written. I’ll discuss some of them in more detail in my next post in this series.

Knox’s Commandments:

1. The criminal must be someone mentioned in the early part of the story, but must not be anyone whose thoughts the reader has been allowed to follow.
2. All supernatural or preternatural agencies are ruled out as a matter of course.
3. Not more than one secret room or passage is allowable.
4. No hitherto undiscovered poisons may be used, nor any appliance which will need a long scientific explanation at the end.
5. No Chinaman must figure in the story. (I told they were dated!)
6. No accident must ever help the detective, nor must he ever have an unaccountable intuition which proves to be right.
7. The detective must not himself commit the crime.
8. The detective must not light on any clues which are not instantly produced for the inspection of the reader.
9. The stupid friend of the detective, the Watson, must not conceal any thoughts which pass through his mind; his intelligence must be slightly, but very slightly, below that of the average reader.
10. Twin brothers, and doubles generally, must not appear unless we have been duly prepared for them.

The Detection Club

Knox’s Commandments – The 10 Rules of Golden Age Detective Fiction, Part 2