The Cozy Mystery List Blog

Cozy Mystery (and Other Favorite) Books, Movies, and TV

Eva Gates: Lighthouse Library Mysteries

July 14, 2020

By Book or By Crook (A Lighthouse Library Mystery 1) This time around, I decided to read a multi-themed Cozy as part of my series about the most popular and recommended mystery series. This book incorporates no less than three Cozy mystery themes – librarians, lighthouses, and cats! Two of these, librarians and cats are among the most popular of all the themes. 

I read By Book or by Crook, the first in the Lighthouse Library Mystery Series by Eva Gates. Eva Gates, you may already know, also writes several popular series as Vicki Delany. (It still mystifies me why such a popular author needs to write under two names — oh well, it is lucky for us that the world is full of mysteries!)

The story follows Lucy Richardson, the new assistant librarian at the Bodie Island Lighthouse Library. (By the way, in an “Author’s Note” at the beginning of the book, we learn that although the lighthouse actually exists, it is not big enough in real life for a library or much else that the book’s lighthouse contains.)

Lucy has newly arrived from Boston. She has arrived just in time for a very special exhibit — a complete set of Jane Austen’s first editions on loan for a few months. In celebration of the arrival of these special books, the library hosts a small party for staff and board members to see the books for the first time. During the party, as is often the case in Cozy Mysteries, a murder occurs. 

Of course, the person murdered as disliked and/or hated by quite of few of the library staff and board members. So, it is a real mystery that must be solved. Lucy is especially interested in discovering the culprit since one of the prime suspects is Bertie, the head librarian who recently hired Lucy.

Besides the usual long list of suspects, the small town also includes several other characters, including two different men who are interested in Lucy as well as the murder. The first, Connor McNeil, is the mayor of the town and an old acquaintance of Lucy who first met Connor during one of the summer vacations that her family had spent in the area. The second, Butch Greenblatt, a police officer. Before the party is over, both Connor and Butch have asked Lucy out of for a date at the new seafood restaurant in town. (I must have been doing something wrong when I was single. When I moved to a new town, this never happened to me!!)

I forgot to mention another important character, the cat, Charles (Dickens), who spends his time in the library and ends up living with Lucy in the small apartment inside the lighthouse above the library.

The book is a charming delight of a read. I zoomed through the pages trying to solve the mystery before the plucky Lucy could do so. Fun and light (in the good sense of the word), By Book or by Crook is a delightful start to a Cozy series that hits all the right notes.

P.S. If you are interested in reading some of the other entries about highly recommended Cozy Mystery series, you can find them at the Most Recommended Cozy Mystery Series page on the site.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

30 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

Barbara Ross: Maine Clambake Mystery Series

June 23, 2020

Clammed Up (A Maine Clambake Mystery Book 1) This month, as part of my continuing effort to cover at least one classic or highly recommended Cozy mystery every month, I’ve read the first entry in Barbara Ross‘s Maine Clambake Mystery Series, Clammed Up.

Julia Snowden has gone back to her family home in Busman’s Harbor, Maine, for the summer. A national economic recession and a poorly timed bank loan to try to expand before the economy broke have left the Snowden Family Clambake Company in dire straits, and Julia’s expertise in finance make her the perfect person to attempt a last-ditch financial solution before the bank calls the loan in.

The Snowden family has run their clambake company for about half a century, running guests out to their privately owned Morrow Island to partake in some of the finest delicacies the local waters can offer, a remote island several hours away by boat.

One of the parts of the financial solution includes opening up the clambake to new and different clienteles other than the regular twice-daily tourist crowd, such as offering early season special outings like wedding receptions. Unfortunately, the first such wedding reception is ruined by the discovery of a body on the island, that of the best man – and in the best classic mystery fashion, it seems like everyone has some sort of motive for doing him in.

One thing I really appreciated about Clammed Up is that the mystery is revealed almost immediately at the outset of the book. While there is a lot to be said for establishing a strong setting and cast, many novels tend to “meander” through the lives of the protagonist for far too long before getting to the mystery, especially in the first entry of the series. That isn’t the case here.

That isn’t to say that this establishment doesn’t occur – there is a great deal of time taken up in the first half of the novel with establishing the community, the family’s routine, what an average clambake is like, and other similar details. But all of it takes place with the murder already firmly established and in mind, which really helps a novel for someone like myself who appreciates the mystery as much as its backdrop.

Another thing I really love about Clammed Up is the cast. In some cases, the urge to make Cozy characters feel “unique” and “quirky” can backfire, making them feel more like caricatures than genuine characters. Clammed Up doesn’t fall into that trap – less sympathetic figures in the town still feel like people trying to do the best job they can under trying circumstances, rather than stubborn obstructionists that are outright trying to either ruin the Snowden family or cover up the crime (well, aside from the criminal, of course).

If you’re looking for a great Cozy set in a scenic, picturesque setting with interesting but believable characters and an engaging mystery that will present itself almost immediately, I can strongly recommend Clammed Up. I feel that this might be an especially good Cozy for those of us who are missing our own summers just a little bit more this year, as it can let you escape to the scenic seaside, if only for a bit.

P.S. As always, if you are interested in reading some of the other entries about highly recommended Cozy Mystery series, you can find them at the Most Recommended Cozy Mystery Series page on the site.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

36 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

Ginger Bolton: Deputy Donut Mystery Series

May 13, 2020

Survival of the Fritters (A Deputy Donut Mystery Book 1) Do you sometimes read a mystery book and find yourself just lost in the book so much that the characters, the setting and the overall tone of the book is so enjoyable that you are not even trying to solve the mystery? This just happened to me when I read The Survival of the Fritters, the first book in Ginger Bolton’s Deputy Donut Mystery Series which is the next book in my quest to cover some of the most popular and recommended mystery series. When I got near to finishing this book, I suddenly realized that the mystery was being revealed, and I had not even really tried to solve it myself!

Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying there is anything wrong with the mystery in this book — far from it! Maybe it was just the mood I was in, but I was enjoying the writing and being in the small northern Wisconsin town of Fallingbrook so much, the ending just kind of crept up on me.

The story opens in the Deputy Donut donut shop. Emily Westhill, our sleuth, and her father-in-law, Tom Westhill (who was the ex-chief of police of the town) run the Deputy Donut shop. Emily is actually the widow of Tom’s son Alec, who was a police detective in the town until he was shot and killed on duty. Emily and Alec were only married four years before he was killed, and Emily is still in her twenties. 

The little donut shop is frequented by many of the town’s people including quite a few members of the police force. Also often there are the Knitpickers, a group who, not surprisingly, are knitters. On this particular day, however, one of the regular Knitpickers, Georgia, was not there. By the end of the day, the Knitpickers had returned to the Deputy Donut shop in order to get Emily to go with them over to Georgia’s house to see what was wrong with her. Being a Cozy Mystery, of course, before long a body was discovered and Emily begins her side job of sleuthing!

The town has a lot of charm. Reading about Emily and her friends reminded me about why I enjoy Cozies so much. Emily has a wonderful little house. And she has a cat with the same name as her shop — Deputy Donut, which she shortens to “Dep” most of the time. Living right behind her in an identical house is Lois who has a long connection to Georgia. So Lois helps Emily with her snooping about. The town has a number of characters who could be involved with the murder(s), so if you are needing to practice your sleuthing skills, the clues and the suspects abound in this book.

But, as I said earlier, I was just along for the ride in this one — for once I left the solving of the mystery to the book’s sleuth! How about you, does this ever happen to you? (I don’t solve most of the mysteries in the books I read, but I sure do enjoy trying!) 

By the way, the author has another very popular series that she wrote as Janet Bolin, the Threadville Mystery Series. 

P.S. As always, if you are interested in reading some of the other entries about highly recommended Cozy Mystery series, you can find them at the Most Recommended Cozy Mystery Series page on the site.

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

30 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

Daryl Wood Gerber: Cookbook Nook Mystery Series

February 25, 2020

Final Sentence (A Cookbook Nook Mystery 1) This month, I read the first entry in the Cookbook Nook Mystery Series by Daryl Wood Gerber (aka Avery Aames), titled Final Sentence. This is yet another entry in my (mostly) monthly series about the most popular and recommended Cozy Mystery series.

Marketing expert Jenna Hart has returned to her home town of Crystal Cove, a small coastal town in California known for both water sports like skiing and surfing as well as crafting stores for things like knitting, sewing, and embroidery, after the death of her husband left her with little desire to remain in San Francisco at her advertising job. Still, she’s going to be keeping her business skills busy enough, as she’s helping her Aunt Vera open a culinary themed bookshop and cafe.

To that end, she’s invited her old college roommate, celebrity chef Desiree Devine, to do a cookbook signing at the cafe’s grand opening. Unfortunately, Desiree brings more than just her autographing hand to the opening – she brings drama as well, in the form of her dodgy boyfriend/director, her jealous sister, and her self-absorbed masseur. Oh, and a potential motive for Jenna herself to take a sudden dislike Desiree, as the aforementioned jealous sister lets slip that Jenna’s deceased husband may or may not have had an affair with Desiree at some point.

With all that baggage, it’s hardly any surprise when Desiree turns up dead, concealed in a sand mermaid sculpture on the beach. Naturally, Jenna is both shocked and pained when she finds the body – though hurt by the thought that her friend may have had an affair with her husband, she never would have hurt her, and hadn’t even had a chance to clear the air on whether or not such an affair had even occurred yet. But the  – a motive made more believable when the local police chief’s own mother indicates she saw Jenna and Desiree speaking on the very beach the corpse was found on.

Fortunately, Jenna has people in her corner as well. Her Aunt Vera, her father – a former FBI analyst – and even the local police chief, who was something of a protege of her father’s, all seem less than convinced that Jenna committed the crime. Still, that doesn’t make Jenna feel any more secure, and it isn’t long before she’s investigating herself – not only to find out who killer her friend, but also to see if her friend had had an affair with her husband.

Final Sentence may not exactly break the mold for modern Cozies, but it certainly does a good job of making a nice, pleasant setting for the characters to live in. At the same time, it gives enough attention to the murder and introduces new clues enough to keep the investigation element engaging. If you’re interested in a culinary-themed Cozy with a coastal setting and a decent mystery, this might be just what you’re looking for.

If you’d like to see other entries about some of the most recommended Cozy Mystery authors, be sure to check out the Most Popular and Recommended Cozy Mystery Series page on my site.

PS: For those who love recipes, this one does include a number of them at the end – deserts, in this case!

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

13 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

« Previous Page
Next Page »

Subscribe to Blog Post Email Alerts

  • Cozy Mystery Blog Home
  • Cozy Mystery Site
  • Soon to be Released Mysteries
  • Cozies by Themes
  • New Mystery Releases
  • New Mystery Series
  • Cozy Mystery Recommendations
  • Most Popular and Recommended Cozy Mystery Series
  • Holiday Mystery Book Lists
  • What Is a Cozy?
  • TV and Movies
  • Author Interviews
  • Cozy-Mystery.com on Facebook

Recent Posts

  • June 9 to June 29
  • TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES CHANNEL MYSTERY MOVIES – July 2025
  • May 19 to June 8
  • Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025
  • J.C. Eaton: Sophie Kimball Mystery Series

Recent Comments

  • Danna - cozy mystery list on TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES CHANNEL MYSTERY MOVIES – July 2025
  • Danna - cozy mystery list on TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES CHANNEL MYSTERY MOVIES – July 2025
  • Kim on Television Mystery Series… What to Start With?… (Part 2)
  • Kim on TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES CHANNEL MYSTERY MOVIES – July 2025
  • Michael on Mystery Books that Take Place in New Jersey …

Cozy Mystery List Home | Affiliate Disclosure | Cozy Mystery Blog Home  | Cozy Mystery Blog Sitemap | Privacy Policy  | Contact Me   | About |

Copyright © 2006-2025, Cozy-Mystery.Com, All rights reserved.
A Guide to Cozy Mystery Books, Movies, and TV


MENU
  • Cozy Mystery Blog Home
  • Cozy Mystery Site
  • Soon to be Released Mysteries
  • Cozies by Themes
  • New Mystery Releases
  • New Mystery Series
  • Cozy Mystery Recommendations
  • Most Popular and Recommended Cozy Mystery Series
  • Holiday Mystery Book Lists
  • What Is a Cozy?
  • TV and Movies
  • Author Interviews
  • Cozy-Mystery.com on Facebook