The Cozy Mystery List Blog

Cozy Mystery (and Other Favorite) Books, Movies, and TV

What’s Up with Her Mystery Books?

January 6, 2013

Patti S. brought up another good point yesterday in her comment. I started writing my response to her comment, and realized it was way too long, so I decided to write an entry as my response.

Patti S.:

“I agree that some authors really stretch out a story. I have hit another problem. I have read a mystery series of a certain author since the first book, but the last two I didn’t even finish. Something in her writing is missing, it just doesn’t have the “catch” that her earlier ones did. They did not hold my attention at all. I have been trying to figure out why and all I can think of is that her writing has changed in some way. I am so disappointed!”

(By the way, I should probably warn those of you who don’t like my “Rants and Raves” that this is one of my Rants!)

Patti S, I have SO been there!!! I “make myself” continue reading a favorite author at least two books after I feel like dropping him/her >>> at least I try to read two more books!

I have one author who I absolutely loved reading. I was quite lucky, too, since she is so doggone prolific. She has written over fifty mystery books, so I could always count on having more of her books in my reading future. But I then found that I got to the point where I wasn’t even looking forward to her book release dates, let alone reading her books. (This has happened with many of the authors on my Favorite Authors list.)

I wonder if “very established” authors don’t reach a sort of complacency, sort of an “I can do no wrong, my fans will love me regardless” attitude. I felt like she was simply putting out two (or even four) mystery books a year >>> for the money. Don’t get me wrong, I realize writing is a profession, and she should be paid for her efforts. But her books seemed like they were being “phoned in”. They were formulaic and repetitive. The mysteries tended to be wrapped up in the last chapter, almost making me think she had a word deadline she had to make. (Sort of like: “Whoops! The publisher is only paying me for X amount of words, I only have to write 300 more, I had better wrap it up now.”)

This author’s books had the same personal relationship being played over and over, and over again. I like a little “will-they-get-together or won’t-they” >>> but, come on!!! How many books was it going to take until they did (or didn’t) get together?!? I hoped they would get together during the first +/-7 books, but after that, frankly, my dear, I didn’t care – AT ALL! I  was reading a mystery series, and wanted the focus to be on that!

It’s a big disappointment when this happens, and it leads me to again say, I would rather an author simply wrap up a series than put out substandard books. I have to wonder why publishers continue to publish series when they start to go down.

I’m guessing it has to do with President Truman’s “The buck stops here.” Only, the “buck” in this case is “$$$$$”.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

25 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

Do 300+ Page Books Deliver a Better Mystery than 200+ Page Books?

January 4, 2013

Good grief! I am reading the second book in a series I thought I would love, but I just can’t seem to get into it. The first book had a good mystery, likable characters, the writing flowed, and the book seemed to promise me it was the first mystery book in what would be a really fun series. (I added the author to my “favorite authors” list.) But, the last few nights I have found myself wondering why I am reading this book.

With over 300 pages, it just seems like the author is using the “stretching” method. You know, putting a lot of unnecessary “fluff” into the book. But since I don’t buy my books like I do my produce, the book’s actual weight (the longer the book, the heavier) doesn’t matter. Do I really want to read the word-by-word exchanges the sleuth has with each of her friends? Do I really need to know every time she drinks a cup of coffee or hot chocolate? Do I really like the sleuth that much, that I’m willing to spend my time reading all of this “filler”?

I know I have commented (several times!) about the length of my books. If I’m going to read a 300+ page book, it had better have 300+ pages of plot. Recently I have found myself wondering if publishers demand 300+ pages from their authors.

I just went to Agatha Christie’s page, and clicked on the links for (more than) several of her books. Why is it that someone like Christie can write a mystery book with 3-D characters, lovely settings, great plots, and interesting mysteries in 200+ pages yet it seems like now it takes 100 more pages to do the same? Do publishers think that we judge our mystery books by their length? Do people feel “cheated” if the book is really good, but doesn’t take that long to read? Am I getting impatient with the 300+ length of books, when I don’t feel they have 300+ pages of interesting reading?

Perhaps an even better question would be “Am I really just nitpicking?”

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

110 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

Happy New Year!

January 1, 2013

January17

Happy New Year to ALL of you!

I am wishing that 2013 be safe, healthy, happy, and downright amazing for ALL of you.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

15 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

Favorite Cozy Mystery Reads for 2012

December 31, 2012

Ay! 2012 is on its way out! I can barely believe a whole year has passed since this very calendar day of last year! Where has the time gone?!? I have been so lucky to have both of my adult children living so close to my husband and me. Our son is here in San Antonio, and our daughter in Austin, 75 miles away. Perhaps that is why the year seems to have flown. I truly believe that while our daughter lived in Cambridge, the years seemed to just drudge on and on. I wish they would go by faster when the goings are good, and slow down when we are content!

As this is my last entry of 2012, I thought I would end the year by posting a terrific, suggested “theme” of Lynn T:

“Since 2012 is winding down, I just had an idea for a December/January blog or discussion. Amazon always has their top books for 2012. We could list our top 5 (or less) favorite reads for 2012. Just an idea. Maybe with our monthly favorites, you feel this would be repetitious.

I would be interested in learning what were the absolute favorites of  the cozy-mystery blog readers for the year of 2012.”

I am going to start the list by saying that I have read a lot of really good Cozy Mystery books this year, as well as some real stinkers, some of which I couldn’t even keep interested in for my “50 page rule.” Yes, I’m sorry to admit it, but some of these books were full of idiotic twists, paper-thin characters, and sleuths that (and notice I didn’t say “sleuths who” – since they couldn’t have been considered fully developed “people”) decided to take it upon themselves to confront a murderer, since they were indeed the sleuths, and the author knew they would have to stick around for the next installment of the series. Good grief!!!

Anyway, to get back to Lynn T’s idea, I have read several really good Cozy Mystery books this year, but since most of them were books by authors who were already on my “favorite authors” list, I thought I would tell you about my new “find” this year. Don’t get me wrong, I have added a few new-to-me authors to my “favorites” list, but this author is someone who, I am pretty sure I would have found on my own. Since I wrote an entry about this author, I will post the entry to explain why I selected him.

Tarquin Hall: Files of Vish Puri Mystery Series (Here is an entry that explains why I picked Hall.)

So, would you tell us about your Favorite Cozy Mystery Reads for 2012, and why you picked these books or authors. Thank you!

As usual with these types of entries, I will add the books/authors who you all comment about to the list:

Favorite Cozy Mystery Reads for 2012

Ellery Adams (aka J. B. Stanley, Jennifer Stanley, & 1/2 of Lucy Arlington): Written in Stone (Books by the Bay Mystery Series)

Susan Wittig Albert: The Darling Dahlias and the Cucumber Tree (Darling Dahlias Mystery Series)

Susan Wittig Albert: Cat’s Claw (Pecan Springs Mystery Series)

Donna Andrews: Meg Langslow Mystery Series

Suzanne Arruda: Jade del Cameron Mystery Series

Marian Babson: all of her books, especially her Trixie & Evangeline Mystery Series

Donald Bain & “Jessica Fletcher”: Murder, She Wrote Mystery Series

Nevada Barr: The Rope (Anna Pigeon Mystery Series

Lorna Barrett (aka L. L. Bartlett & Lorraine Bartlett): Booktown Mystery Series

M. C. Beaton: Agatha Raisin Mystery Series

Rhys Bowen: Molly Murphy Mystery Series

Rhys Bowen: Lady Georgiana Mystery Series

Lilian Jackson Braun: The Cat Who ***** Mystery Series

Simon Brett: Fethering Mystery Series

Jennifer Chiaverini: Elm Creek Quilts Series (not a mystery)

Laura Childs

Kate Collins: Flower Shop Mystery Series

Cleo Coyle (aka Alice Kimberly): Coffee House Mystery Series

Deborah Crombie:  Kincaid & James Mystery Series

Mary Daheim: Emma Lord Mystery Series

Diane Mott Davidson: Goldy Bear Mystery Series

Krista Davis: Domestic Diva Mystery Series

Jo Dereske: Miss Zukas Mystery Series

Monica Ferris: Needlecraft Mystery Series

Amanda Flower: A Plain Death (Appleseed Creek Mystery Series)

Sue Grafton: V is for Vengeance (Kinsey Milhone Mystery Series

Kerry Greenwood: Phryne Fisher Mystery Series

Kerry Greenwood: Corinna Chapman Mystery Series

John Grisham: The Litigators

Tarquin Hall: Files of Vish Puri Mystery Series (Here is an entry that explains why I picked Hall.)

Victoria Hamilton: Vintage Kitchen Mystery Series

David Handler: Berger & Mitry Mystery Series

Veronica Heley: Murder in Mind (Ellie Quicke Mystery Series)

Joan Hess: Deader Homes and Gardens (Claire Malloy Mystery Series)

Hazel Holt: Mrs. Malory Mystery Series

Maddy Hunter: Dutch Me Deadly (Passport to Peril Mystery Series)

Miranda James (aka Dean James, Honor Hartman, & Jimmie Ruth Evans): Cat in the Stack Mystery Series

J.A. Jance: Left for Dead (Ali Reynolds Mystery Series )

J.A. Jance: Judgement Call (Joanna Brady Mystery Series

Laurie R. King: Mary Russell/Sherlock Holmes Mystery Series

Jill Marie Landis: Tikki Goddess Mystery Series

Laura Levine: Jaine Austen Mystery Series

Karen MacInerney: Gray Whale Inn Mystery Series

Charlotte MacLeod (aka Alisa Craig): The Family Vault (Sarah Kelling Mystery Series)

Charlotte MacLeod (aka Alisa Craig): Rest You Merry (Peter Shandy Mystery Series)

Susan Elia MacNeal: Maggie Hope Mystery Series

Margaret Maron: Deborah Knott Mystery Series

Jenn McKinlay (aka Lucy Lawrence & Josie Belle): Cupcake Bakery Mystery Series

Amy Patricia Meade: Don’t Die Under the Apple Tree (Rosie the Riveter Mystery Series)

Marcia Muller: City of Whispers and Looking for Yesterday (Sharon McCone Mystery Series)

Louise Penny: A Beautiful Mystery (Chief Inspector Gamache Mystery Series)

Terri Reid: Mary O’Reilly Paranormal Mystery Series

Hank Phillippi Ryan: The Other Woman (Jane Ryland & Jake Brogan Mystery Series)

Maggie Sefton: Knitting Mystery Series

Joanna Campbell Slan: Kiki Lowenstein Scrap-n-Craft Mystery Series

Dana Stabenow: Restless in the Grave (Kate Shugak Mystery Series)

Victoria Thompson: Gaslight Mystery Series

Elaine Viets: Murder is a Piece of Cake (Mystery Shopper Mystery Series)

Jacqueline Winspear: Maisie Dobbs Mystery Series

Suzanne Young: Edna Davies Mystery Series

If you’re interested in seeing a whole lot more recommendations made by Cozy Mystery readers, click here: Monthly Cozy Mystery Recommendations.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

27 Comments - Click Here to Read the Comments or to Add Another

« Previous Page
Next Page »

Subscribe to Blog Post Email Alerts

  • Cozy Mystery Blog Home
  • Cozy Mystery Site
  • Soon to be Released Mysteries
  • Cozies by Themes
  • New Mystery Releases
  • New Mystery Series
  • Cozy Mystery Recommendations
  • Most Popular and Recommended Cozy Mystery Series
  • Holiday Mystery Book Lists
  • What Is a Cozy?
  • TV and Movies
  • Author Interviews
  • Cozy-Mystery.com on Facebook

Recent Posts

  • Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025
  • J.C. Eaton: Sophie Kimball Mystery Series
  • TURNER CLASSIC MOVIES CHANNEL MYSTERY MOVIES – June 2025
  • April 28 to May 18
  • Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – April 2025

Recent Comments

  • M.E.H. on Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025
  • Hanna on Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025
  • Mrs. Ainee C. Beland on Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025
  • Linda MH on Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025
  • Fortney, Sally on Cozy Mystery Book Recommendations – May 2025

Cozy Mystery List Home | Affiliate Disclosure | Cozy Mystery Blog Home  | Cozy Mystery Blog Sitemap | Privacy Policy  | Contact Me   | About |

Copyright © 2006-2025, Cozy-Mystery.Com, All rights reserved.
A Guide to Cozy Mystery Books, Movies, and TV


MENU
  • Cozy Mystery Blog Home
  • Cozy Mystery Site
  • Soon to be Released Mysteries
  • Cozies by Themes
  • New Mystery Releases
  • New Mystery Series
  • Cozy Mystery Recommendations
  • Most Popular and Recommended Cozy Mystery Series
  • Holiday Mystery Book Lists
  • What Is a Cozy?
  • TV and Movies
  • Author Interviews
  • Cozy-Mystery.com on Facebook