The Cozy Mystery List Blog

Cozy Mystery (and Other Favorite) Books, Movies, and TV

Lord Peter Wimsey series…

The Lord Peter Wimsey Mysteries: Set 1 One series that we particularly enjoy is the Lord Peter Wimsey series. Actually, there are two different versions of the Lord Peter Wimsey series (by the great author Dorothy L. Sayers)…. one series was made in the 1970s and the other was made in the 1980s. (This article will be about the 1970s version. My next article will be about the 1980s miniseries.)

When I started watching the BBC 1970s version, I wasn’t quite sure if I would stay with the series, or not. It was “different” than any other series I had watched… the shows almost seemed a bit “campy.” But,  I finally decided to stay with the series, and boy (!) am I ever glad that I did!  If anything, now that my husband has seen the series, we are really sorry that there are only five different episodes. (Not to worry, each of the episodes is given three hours or more… so they aren’t crammed into the normal 52 minute format.)  I first saw the series on PBS, when it aired on Masterpiece Theatre. You may be asking why it was on Masterpiece Theatre and not Mystery!… but for those of you old enough to remember “way back then”, you will know that there was no such show as Mystery!…  And, rumor has it that this wonderful mystery series is what prompted Masterpiece Theatre to fork out into the Mystery! show.

Dorothy L. Sayers  is known to most mystery readers as one of the great mystery writers of all times. After Oxford, she taught school and also worked as a copywriter for an advertising firm. Her first Lord Peter Wimsey novel (Whose Body?) was published in the early 1920s.

Ian Carmichael stars as Lord Peter Wimsey in this BBC production. Clouds of Witness, Murder Must Advertise, The Unpleasantness at the Bellona Club, The Nine Tailors, and Five Red Herrings are the titles of the different miniseries, which of course, are based on the novels of the same names.

The Lord Peter Wimsey collection  is one of the few miniseries series that features an aristocratic sleuth who is actually smarter than his butler! Bunter, while smart, is still no match for his employer. Inspector Parker, who befriends Lord Peter Wimsey and falls for Lord Wimsey’s sister, Lady Mary (“Polly”) is refreshingly smart, also. (Sometimes, when you have a main sleuthing character it is almost perfunctory to have a bungling police force…. which is not the case in these shows.)

(Here is a list of the novels by Dorothy L. Sayers.)

If you would like to see more TV and Movies suggestions, click here.

Brother Cadfael series…..

Ellis Peters (Edith Pargeter) had the right idea when she came up with the Brother Cadfael character. She chose to base this series on a twelfth century Benedictine monk who had a “past life.” This past life enabled him to have empathy for people…. both of noble lineage and the very poor. Peters included many actual historical events throughout the series

Brother Cadfael had been a crusader in his “previous life” so he had experienced the agony of killing, and he had also experienced romantic liaisons. Sir Derek Jacobi was able to, in my opinion, become Brother Cadfael. Jacobi seems to be an actor who, when he takes on a roll, makes it very difficult for any other actor to ever attempt that roll in the future…. Jacobi is simply that good at every character he portrays.

Brother Cadfael is a monk who is in charge of the abbey’s gardens…. which meant that he is knowledgeable in herbs, and their medicinal purposes. Also, he is knowledgeable about the very same herbs poisonous effects. Cadfael is truly a medieval monk of all trades…. herbalist, healer/doctor, embalmer/mortician, forensic pathologist, detective/sleuth, confessor, and true protector/champion for victims’ rights.

The location is so incredibly believable as twelfth century Britain, that it is interesting to note that the producers filmed the series in Hungary, because they wanted the setting to be as true to medieval Britain as possible. Hungary happened to fill the bill better than any place they could find in England. Thank goodness they did……. because the ITV productions’ locations are wonderful. (ITV is one of the BBC’s competitors.)

While Ellis Peters wrote twenty books, the British Cadfael: the Complete Collection series only includes thirteen of the possible twenty titles. What a shame! They are truly excellent productions. My husband and I enjoyed seeing them when they originally aired a little over a decade ago, but we have since added all thirteen of the shows to our library of “must see TV” for our children, who enjoy the shows as much as we do.

Ellis Peters’ Brother Cadfael Mystery Series is a terrific series. Peters is actually one of my favorite authors. Here is a list of all twenty of the Brother Cadfael novels by Ellis Peters.

If you would like to see more TV and Movies suggestions, click here.

*****I wrote this review way back in 2006, but we still think it’s a terrific series. If you are a member of Netflix, they have the DVDs. Also, your library might just carry the DVDs. It truly is an exceptional British television mystery series. April 2014

Barchester Chronicles miniseries…

Although, technically, the Barchester Chronicles miniseries is not a mystery, it certainly qualifies as “cozy.” This miniseries is a favorite of ours— not only because of its terrific plot, or because it stars some wonderful actors (Geraldine McEwan, Nigel Hawthorne, Alan Rickman, Donald Pleasence, Clive Swift, Susan Hampshire, ETC) but also because the scenery is absolutely and wonderfully British.

The BBC production is based on two of Anthony Trollope’s novels (Barchester Towers and the Warden), and deals with the power struggles between those who are truly good people and those who only have the appearance of being good because of their chosen professions. (This is quite a brief summary of the plot!) I first saw the production years ago when it originally aired on Masterpiece Theatre. You cannot imagine how excited I was when I discovered that it was available now on DVD. I lost absolutely no time in getting it so that my family could enjoy it. And, they have!

One thing to remember, though, is that the Barchester Chronicles was made in 1982, and was meant to air on television. So, although the settings are beautiful, and the plot is delightfully “cozy” – it does not have the appearance of today’s productions. But,  even without today’s razzle-dazzle special effects and the multi-million dollar salaries spent to procure “major stars,” it is one of our very favorite shows.

If you would like to see more TV and Movies suggestions, click here.

*****I wrote this review way back in 2006, but we still think it’s a terrific series. If you are a member of Netflix, they have the DVDs. Also, your library might just carry the DVDs. It truly is an exceptional British television mystery series. May 2014

MENU