Cyril Hare who was an English judge (his real name was Alfred Alexander Gordon Clark) was an author who wrote towards the tail end of the period that many would consider the classic mystery book period. He wrote from the 1930s to the 1950s, and Tenant for Death was first published in 1937. Cyril Hare’s total output was quite a bit less than some of the other classic period mystery authors. For example, the Inspector Mallet series only has six books that were published over 21 years.
In this story, we are introduced to Inspector Mallet, a rather tall and stout man with a big appetite. He often seems to interrupt his sleuthing to refuel by going out to eat. His assistant is Detective-Sergeant Frant who is industrious and somewhat mystified by some of Inspector Mallet’s methods which include doing a lot of thinking (to the point of falling asleep in the office) and eating.
Nevertheless, Inspector Mallet is very successful. In this case, a high stakes financier, Mr. Ballentine, who committed a multiple-year fraud and was about to get caught goes missing and is found dead in a house that had been rented by a mysterious character. Mr. Ballentine’s disappearance happened just days after the release from prison of one of his earlier fraud victims who had said that he would see him dead.
The book is a leisurely read. The discovery of the body is not until around the book’s 15% point. This pace is not what you see in most modern Cozies, but I have to say that after reading a bunch of newer Cozies and then going to Cyril Hare, I did find it oddly attractive to read a book where the discovery of the body does not happen in the first few pages.
The setting is 1930s London and its surroundings which I found very interesting. Although Inspector Mallet is not an amateur sleuth (far from it!!), the book does have a Cozy atmosphere, although not the type found in modern Cozies. There is no small town, no heroine who inherits a shop, and the sleuth does not have to sneak around behind the backs of the police detectives, as examples.
The book has an old fashioned feel to it — mostly because it is an old-style mystery written so long ago. In the end, the clues are all gathered and laid out for the reader. All of the information that Inspector Mallet ends up thinking deeply about (remember what I said about him falling asleep at his office!) are available to the reader. Nothing significant is held back, so the reader has a fair chance to be a partner in discovering the murderer and the other mysteries involved in the story.
I found Tenant for Death a different and refreshing break from reading new Cozies (which I love too!!).
Click here to read more posts about the most popular and recommended Cozy Mystery series.
Elizabeth Leo says
Oh, yes! I had forgotten Cyril Hare! 40 years ago I read all of these! I still have them & will be whiling away my summer rereading every single one. Thanks for the delightful memory.
Danna - cozy mystery list says
Elizabeth, you’re welcome! As much as I enjoy highlighting newer series, every so often I love coming back to an old favorite like this one.
Elaine Behrendt says
Now I don’t have to read the book!! I don’t know why I read these reviews, they ruin the stories.
Danna - cozy mystery list says
Elaine, I certainly hope it doesn’t spoil the mystery as a whole! I try not to include any definite details after the “setup” part of the mystery.
Bek says
I think I may have to try this. That’s what I love about the older mysteries, they unfold, they aren’t thrown at you willy-nilly.
Danna - cozy mystery list says
Bek, there’s certainly something to be said for a book that puts the mystery first, and sorts other details around the mystery rather than around the sleuth’s hobby (or non-sleuth day job, as the case may be).
Novella says
Sounds good, love the older mysteries! never heard of this one before. I have been making it through the alphabetical author list and checking them out when I have time and not reading! Thanks for pointing me in yet another good direction. Your info here in invaluable to us all.
Danna - cozy mystery list says
Novella, you’re welcome, and I hope you enjoy this series!
PamB says
Danna, you do a wonderful job of introducing readers to many types of authors by highlighting the authors first book of a series. I have found many favorite authors by reading your synopsis. I just finished reading a Nero Wolfe mystery…The Doorbell Rang..and it was ‘a different and refreshing break’ and oh so good. Thank you for all the time you put into this blog and the cozy mystery
site.
Danna - cozy mystery list says
PamB, you’re welcome! And I should probably write something about the Nero Wolfe series sometime soon as well…
Yvonne says
Love this blog! Thanks for all you do for us cozy mystery readers!
Danna - cozy mystery list says
Yvonne, you’re welcome!
KG says
There are some series I would have never tried, but for your reviews. Thank you for taking the time and effort to write a synopsis and review.
Danna - cozy mystery list says
KG, I’m glad that the reviews help! You’re welcome.